Expertise Into Influence: Tina Fordham
By Katherine • • 4 min read
What does the next generation of female leaders need from publishing?
In our miniseries, we’re exploring how publishing can help to create the conditions for the next generation of female thinkers, experts and leaders to thrive.
At Whitefox, we have the privilege of working with remarkable women whose ideas shape conversations across business, leadership, policy, culture and society. We spoke to five Whitefox authors – Emily Ross, Tina Fordham, Anita Mendiratta, Gamze Yucaoglu and Galya Molinas – to get their perspectives on how publishing can better support leading female voices and help transform expertise into influence. We posed questions to each of them around authority, visibility, platform-building, audience development and the changing nature of thought leadership itself.
Here are Tina Fordham’s thoughts on the ‘Authority Gap’ for female experts. Tina is the Founder of Fordham Global Foresight and author of Mad World: A Geostrategy Survival Guide for Leaders.
Head to our Substack, The Writing Type, to read the full article summarising our interviews: The 93% problem: insights from expert female authors.
Does the Authority Gap for Female Experts Lead to a Success Penalty for the Few Who Break Through?
Insights from Tina Fordham:
‘Do you ever get tired of telling important men they are wrong?’
An unsmiling male CEO asked me this question not long ago as I stood on stage taking questions, having delivered a keynote speech on navigating geopolitical complexity to a large audience of international business leaders. Unnerved, I was momentarily unsure how to respond – was he joking? – but opted to go with the honest answer: ‘No, I never do.’ The audience laughed, thankfully. But I knew I was taking a professional risk with my answer.
Mary Ann Sieghart identified this phenomenon in her 2021 book, The Authority Gap, which documents the body of evidence underscoring that women are systematically taken less seriously than men – not only by men, by also by other women. To make matters worse, given that I am a professional adviser to board and C-suite leaders, Sieghart cites research from Linda Carli of Wellesley College, a specialist in the topic of influence, noting that ‘Competent women “can threaten (men’s) sense of entitlement to power, such that they are likely to be resisted as leaders”.’
Paradoxically, it appears that the same qualities that make us leaders in our industries also work against female experts, by turning our prospective clients off, in a malign professional-services variation of the stereotype of men who are disinclined to ask for directions while driving, preferring to get lost instead. Does the ‘authority gap’, then, translate into a success penalty for the few of us who manage to make it as experts?
As an expert on geopolitics with twenty-five-plus years of experience in senior leadership positions spanning investment banking, law, consultancy, government and international organisations, I have become accustomed to not only being the only woman in the room but also having to perpetually ‘audition’ to demonstrate my expertise, despite having a CV that one hedge fund client recently described as ‘gold-plated’, including advising prime ministers and two- and three-star generals, and numerous accolades.
I have always known that I was an outlier, and that it wouldn’t be easy to succeed in a nascent field that I helped to establish (geopolitical strategy for companies and investors). Stubbornly, I have always wanted to believe in the power of excellence for its own sake, and meritocracy. To think otherwise would be too demotivating to contemplate.
With this in mind, I was dismayed to learn in the run-up to publishing my first book that the odds of a female author – in the categories of either business/leadership or global affairs – writing a successful book were considerably worse than the odds I faced in becoming a managing director at a global investment bank. Men are overwhelmingly the primary buyers of books in these categories, and they rarely if ever buy books by female authors. Was my book doomed from the start? I briefly toyed with changing the author’s name to T. M. Fordham, the time-honoured ruse of centuries of female authors before me.
But in addition to being stubborn I also am an optimist, and so I took an executive decision: during my speech at the launch party for my book, Mad World: A Geostrategy Survival Guide for Leaders, I made a direct appeal for support. I asked everyone who came to drink pink champagne and dance to the Mad World playlist to help spread the word about the book, to write reviews and, yes, in our wretched ‘attention economy’, to like, share and comment on social media, because women get far less of this form of ‘social proof’ too. This was another risk, like answering honestly when asked if I minded ‘telling important men they are wrong’.
While I may not be personally narrowing the Authority Gap or changing the statistics for female authors of business books overall, I do know that people like to be part of something, and most of the time are only too happy to help when asked (and given specific ideas about how to do so). So far, I am gratified at the response to Mad World, and how many male allies have answered my call to action. Courage calls to courage everywhere, as suffragette Millicent Fawcett said.
Read more on our Substack: The Writing Type
Like what you see? Share with a friend.